Goodreads alternative
In The Book Club and Goodreads, side by side.
If you like Goodreads, keep it. If you have been wishing for half stars, a did-not-finish shelf, or a proper way to read a book with friends, here is how the two compare. Your Goodreads library comes with you, free.
| Feature | In The Book Club | Goodreads |
|---|---|---|
| Star ratings | Half stars, ½ to 5 | Whole stars only |
| Did not finish | A built-in shelf, with the page you stopped on | No built-in status; readers make a custom shelf |
| Progress updates | By page or percent | By page or percent |
| Yearly reading goal | Yes, with streaks and past years | Yes (Reading Challenge) |
| Re-reads | Yes, each with its own dates | Yes |
| Moods and pace | Yes, from readers’ tags | No |
| Content warnings | Yes, and you can filter recommendations by them | No dedicated field |
| Book clubs | Built in, with a shared book, schedule and member progress | Groups with discussion boards |
| Buddy reads | Built in; comments stay hidden until you reach the page | Not built in |
| Challenges and bingo | Make your own prompt lists and bingo boards | Site-run challenges |
| Year in review | Yes, with a share card | Yes (Year in Books) |
| Moving your library | Imports a Goodreads CSV, free | Exports a CSV |
| Where you can use it | Web and iPhone | Web, iPhone and Android |
| Who owns it | Two people, Joseph and Sadie Leporati | Amazon |
| Price | Free; optional Pro at $49.99 a year | Free |
Goodreads details are as of November 2026. Goodreads is a trademark of its owner; this page is not affiliated with or endorsed by Goodreads.
Where Goodreads is ahead
It has an Android app, and it has been around since 2007, so it has far more members and far more reviews on any given book. In The Book Club is new and small. If the size of the crowd matters most to you, that is a real difference.
How to switch
- On Goodreads, on a computer: My Books, then Import and export, then Export Library.
- Create a free In The Book Club account.
- Choose Import from Goodreads and upload the file. Anything that cannot be matched is listed for you.